This is a known issue in Elementor apparently but from the following github page code snippet by (TheDuvetman) you can add this code to your child themes function file. I have not personally tested this solution.
I'm migrating a site that currently protects a 'Members Only' page where existing members of a golf club can see internal information and member contact information. The general public will not be able to login but can see all the other information for events and golf, tennis, and swimming.
I can export all of the users from the old db...but want users to create a new password by 'failing' the login and resetting with a new password.
The code on the Github page redirects the users back in a loop but doesn't help if I want them to 'Reset/Create' a new password on a 'branded' page. Basically masking the WP logo and in the screen clips below.
I'll totally try the plugins if they'll help with the workaround.